Labels

How Chartered Accountants Exploit Tax Loopholes in India, Burdening Startups, and How Blockchain Can Bring Fairness

Unveiling the Shadows:

In India, tax evasion is not only done by shady businesses—it is often made possible by Chartered Accountants (CAs), who are supposed to protect financial honesty. Some recent investigations by the Income Tax Department revealed refund frauds, black money operations, and fake invoices involving CAs. These expose a bigger problem: many CAs help big companies avoid or even illegally evade taxes, while small startups—without resources—end up paying full compliance costs.

This creates an unfair system: the rich use loopholes to get richer, and startups lose money fighting to stay legal. The good news is—new technologies like blockchain and AI could close these loopholes and make taxation simpler, fairer, and transparent.

How CAs Exploit Tax Loopholes

India’s tax laws (Income Tax Act, GST) are very complicated, and CAs know how to use them—not always honestly. Common tricks include:

  • Fake invoices to wrongly claim GST credits.

  • Using offshore tax havens (like Mauritius or Singapore) to send money out and bring it back untaxed.

  • Transfer pricing manipulation in multinational companies.

  • Bogus donations or misuse of reimbursements.

Many scams prove this:

  • A Rs 110 crore black money case with two CAs.

  • A Rs 792 crore invoicing fraud.

  • Over 22,500 fake tax returns in Tamil Nadu worth crores.

Clearly, these are not mistakes—they are planned schemes. They cost the government huge amounts of money (over Rs 30,000 crore of GST evasion detected recently), while corporations benefit.

Why Startups Suffer More

Big corporates can hire top CAs charging lakhs of rupees to “optimize” taxes using loopholes. Startups, however:

  • Cannot afford such experts.

  • Face high compliance costs (frequent GST filings, audits, rule changes).

  • Get penalized even for small mistakes.

For example, many startups burn precious cash on GST-related compliance instead of growth. Meanwhile, large players escape scrutiny using complex methods, giving them an unfair competitive edge.

Part of the issue is that the CA profession in India is dominated by a few elite professionals trained at high costs, mostly serving wealthy clients. The result: ordinary businesses, startups, and citizens face the real tax burden.

Why This is Unfair

Think of a young entrepreneur barely surviving but paying full taxes, while a corporate giant next door evades crores with the help of CAs. The system is rigged. This reduces government revenue (less money for healthcare, education, infrastructure) and widens inequality.

Even though laws like the Prevention of Money Laundering Act now include GST fraud, enforcement is weak. If this continues, India’s startup ecosystem—already slowed by high compliance demands—will keep suffering.

The Solution: AI and Blockchain

To fix this, India needs a transparent tax system driven by blockchain and artificial intelligence (AI).

  • Blockchain: Creates a public, tamper-proof ledger of all transactions. Prevents fake invoices or manual manipulation.

  • AI: Detects suspicious patterns, predicts tax evasion attempts, and automates filings and audits.

How it could work:

  • All GST invoices, returns, and high-value transactions are recorded on blockchain.

  • AI reviews data in real time, flagging fraud or errors.

  • Startups use simple apps for compliance—no need to pay lakhs to CAs.

  • Tax officers get instant reports, making audits faster and unbiased.

Steps to implement:

  1. Pilot GST e-invoicing with blockchain.

  2. Change laws to allow blockchain-based records.

  3. Give incentives (like tax rebates) for firms adopting it.

  4. Build apps in partnership with private tech players so all businesses can access it.

This is not futuristic. Many countries already test blockchain for taxes. India has already used AI in crypto taxation, recovering over Rs 437 crore in 2024–25.

How Citizens Benefit

Regular taxpayers will also benefit:

  • Tax filing will be as easy as using a banking app.

  • AI will guide users in real-time, suggesting valid deductions and spotting mistakes.

  • Blockchain will give them transparency—showing where their tax money is being spent (schools, hospitals, roads).

  • Strong security ensures personal financial data is safe.

This builds trust in the system and ensures everyone pays their fair share.

What the Government Should Do

India already has a National AI and Blockchain Strategy. To make this real:

  • Expand AI-blockchain pilots in tax administration.

  • Invest in digital infrastructure.

  • Train tax officers to use these systems.

  • Mandate blockchain for high-risk sectors like GST and crypto.

  • Work with startups, tech firms, and citizens for smooth adoption.

The result: more revenue, less fraud, and fairness for all.

Conclusion

Today, powerful corporations use CAs to exploit loopholes, leaving startups and small businesses to suffer. But with AI and blockchain, India can build a fair tax system—transparent, low-cost, and efficient. This will empower startups, protect citizens, and strengthen the economy.

It’s time to demand this change. The future of India’s economy depends on it.

Labels:

Comments

Post a Comment