India Cancelled a Journalist's Visa 10 Minutes Before Her Flight. On Press Day, Both Big Parties Have Questions to Answer.


Helle Lyng had her visa. She had political clearance. She was invited to speak in Hyderabad on press freedom. About ten minutes before she left for the airport on 11 November, a call came from the Indian Embassy in Oslo: her visa had been cancelled. She says the order came from the Ministry of Home Affairs (The Hindu).

She writes for the Oslo daily Dagsavisen. In May, in Oslo, she had asked Prime Minister Narendra Modi a question about press freedom (Arab News).

Congress MP Shashi Tharoor says 115 of 315 cleared speakers at the Congress-linked Bharat Summit were refused entry or had visas cancelled. The Ministry of External Affairs replied with one line: "Visa matters are sovereign functions." The Home Ministry has given no number and no reason. The Editors Guild of India called it "bureaucratic overreach" and asked for reasons (The Hindu).

Today is National Press Day. Every party is posting tributes to fearless journalism.

Now look at the details on the other side

In March 2025, in the same state that hosted this summit, Hyderabad cyber-crime police picked up two women journalists from the YouTube channel Pulse News around 5 a.m. Revathi Pogadadanda, 44, and Thanvi Yadav, 25, were arrested over a video critical of Chief Minister Revanth Reddy of the Congress. The complaint came from a state secretary of the Congress Social Media Cell. Police seized two laptops, two hard disks and seven CPUs (The Indian Express). Police called the video vulgar and abusive. Even so, a 5 a.m. arrest over a video is a choice.

A ten-minute phone call. Seven seized CPUs. Small details tell the big story: whoever holds power finds a tool to silence critics, and then posts a Press Day greeting.

A rebuke for both camps

Ruling-party supporters who cheer the visa cancellations as "keeping out anti-India voices" have not seen a single stated reason. Opposition leaders who call it a shameful attack on free speech owe the same honesty about journalists arrested on their own watch. Press freedom is not a team jersey.

Questions to ask on Press Day

  • What exact law and reason did the government use, and will it say so in public?
  • Does the party praising the press protect reporters where it rules?
  • Is a post about "fearless journalism" backed by any action?
  • Who decides which question is "too critical" to be asked?

If a journalist can lose her visa for one question, and another can be arrested at dawn for one video, how many questions will you be allowed to ask by the time you graduate?

Comments