The State of Our Judiciary: Is Justice Truly Blind, or Does It Know Whom to See First?
Five years after Father Stan Swamy died in judicial custody, the Bombay High Court finally disposed of his pending petition. What does this tell us about the value we place on human life, personal liberty and fundamental rights in India?
There are moments when the failure of an institution becomes more powerful than any criticism one can write about it.
The case of Father Stan Swamy is one such moment.
Father Stan Swamy was an 84-year-old Jesuit priest, a tribal rights activist and a man who spent decades working among marginalised communities in Jharkhand. He was arrested by the National Investigation Agency (NIA) in October 2020 under the Unlawful Activities (Prevention) Act (UAPA) in connection with the Bhima Koregaon case.
He suffered from Parkinson's disease. His hands trembled so badly that he struggled to hold a glass of water. He even had to fight for something as basic as a straw and a sipper in prison.
He repeatedly sought bail.
He died on July 5, 2021, while still in judicial custody, before his bail plea could receive a meaningful resolution.
And now, on November 18, 2026, five years after his death, the Bombay High Court has disposed of his pending petition, observing that it had become infructuous because he was no longer alive.
Think about that for a moment.
A man asks the court for his liberty. He dies waiting. Five years later, the court formally closes the matter because the man who needed justice is dead.
Is this merely a procedural delay, or does it expose a much deeper institutional failure?
The real question: Why can some cases move at extraordinary speed?
Let us examine a few publicly documented examples. Not to argue that these people should have been denied justice, but to ask why urgency appears possible in some cases while others remain trapped in the judicial system.
1. Cases that received urgent attention
Arnab Goswami (2020)
The Supreme Court granted interim bail to journalist Arnab Goswami in an abetment-to-suicide case. The matter received attention within days. Justice D.Y. Chandrachud made a powerful observation: deprivation of liberty, even for one day, is one day too many.
That principle was absolutely correct.
But why did the same sense of urgency not translate into effective protection for an 84-year-old man with Parkinson's disease?
Pawan Khera (2023)
Congress leader Pawan Khera was arrested at Delhi airport in connection with FIRs registered in Assam and Uttar Pradesh. The Supreme Court intervened on the same day and directed that he be granted interim bail.
Arvind Kejriwal, Manish Sisodia, Sanjay Singh and other political leaders (2024)
The Supreme Court dealt with several politically prominent bail matters during 2024, including those involving Arvind Kejriwal, Manish Sisodia, Sanjay Singh, K. Kavitha and Hemant Soren.
These cases involved different facts, different legal questions and different outcomes. The point is not that these individuals were undeserving of a hearing.
The point is that the judicial system has demonstrated that it can hear politically significant and liberty-related cases with considerable urgency.
The Unnao rape survivor
The Supreme Court also intervened in the case involving former BJP MLA Kuldeep Singh Sengar after the Delhi High Court suspended his sentence and granted him bail. In December 2025, the Supreme Court stayed that order. In March 2026, it allowed the survivor to participate in the proceedings challenging the bail.
This was necessary. A rape survivor must have access to justice, protection and a meaningful hearing.
But protecting one person's fundamental rights must never come at the cost of ignoring another person's fundamental rights.
Here is the uncomfortable question:
If the courts can respond to urgent matters involving powerful politicians, prominent personalities and high-profile cases, why is there no equally dependable mechanism to protect an elderly, seriously ill undertrial prisoner who may not survive another month in custody?
This is not an argument against rape survivors receiving urgent justice. It is an argument for making urgency a right, not a privilege.
2. The disturbing question of Father Stan Swamy
There is another detail that deserves public attention.
The petition filed after Swamy's death, through Father Frazer Mascarenhas, sought to challenge the observations made against Swamy by the special court and protect his reputation.
According to LiveLaw, that petition was listed nearly eight times before five different division benches. Three benches recused themselves.
The matter remained unresolved for years.
The High Court eventually disposed of it in December 2025, giving liberty to approach the court with a fresh petition concerning the inquiry into his death. The separate pending petition challenging the rejection of Swamy's bail was disposed of on November 18, 2026.
This is not a small administrative inconvenience. It is a serious question about the ability of our justice system to provide meaningful remedies to people who have already suffered irreversible harm.
And there is an even bigger contradiction.
The Supreme Court has repeatedly emphasised that personal liberty is fundamental. Article 21 of our Constitution protects the right to life and personal liberty.
But what does personal liberty mean if an individual spends years in prison without a trial?
What does the presumption of innocence mean if the accused dies before the judicial system can properly address his plea?
What is the value of a constitutional right if the machinery responsible for protecting it moves slower than the human body deteriorates?
3. The judges must also answer questions
Judges are independent. Their independence is essential to democracy.
But judicial independence should not mean freedom from institutional accountability.
Judges interpret the law. They also control the administration of justice through judicial decisions and, in senior courts, administrative responsibilities.
The public has every right to ask:
Who was responsible for the repeated delays in listing Swamy's bail-related matters?
Why did the matter move between different benches without a timely final resolution?
Were the medical circumstances and advanced age given sufficient weight?
Was there any system to flag cases involving critically ill undertrial prisoners?
Who reviewed the continued delay?
What institutional lessons have been learned from his death?
These are legitimate questions.
We do not need to accuse individual judges of corruption or political favouritism without evidence. We need something more powerful: transparency, records, explanations and measurable accountability.
A judge should not be judged by political popularity. A judge should be judged by the constitutional responsibility entrusted to the office.
4. Who should be held accountable?
Accountability cannot end with a statement that the petition has become infructuous.
There are several institutions whose responsibilities deserve examination.
The trial court: Why was adequate consideration of his medical condition and liberty not achieved in time?
The Bombay High Court: Why did the bail-related proceedings remain unresolved until his death? Why did the subsequent proceedings concerning his reputation and rights take so long?
The Supreme Court: Why is there no effective nationwide mechanism to identify and prioritise elderly, seriously ill undertrial prisoners facing prolonged incarceration?
The NIA and prison authorities: Were his medical needs, dignity and constitutional protections adequately respected?
The judicial administration: Who monitors pending cases where delay could result in irreversible harm?
These questions deserve independent scrutiny, not convenient silence.
5. What should citizens demand?
We cannot leave judicial accountability entirely to judges reviewing other judges.
Citizens must demand structural changes.
1. Public listing transparency: Publish data showing how urgent hearing requests are accepted, rejected and prioritised.
2. Time-bound bail hearings: Establish clear timelines for bail matters involving elderly, critically ill and long-detained undertrial prisoners.
3. Judicial performance transparency: Publish court-wise data on case pendency, adjournments, disposal times and prolonged pre-trial detention.
4. Independent review: Examine cases where an accused person dies in custody while awaiting judicial relief. Establish whether preventable institutional failures contributed to the outcome.
5. Accountability for administrative delays: Identify the officials and administrative processes responsible for unexplained listing delays, with appropriate disciplinary mechanisms where misconduct is established.
6. Equal access to justice: A person's political position, financial resources, social influence, religion or popularity should never determine the speed at which their fundamental rights are protected.
The Supreme Court itself has recognised the danger of prolonged criminal proceedings. In January 2026, it directed High Court Chief Justices to review stalled trials involving serious offences such as murder and rape, warning that prolonged delays could amount to a mockery of justice.
The same seriousness must extend to prolonged pre-trial detention and urgent liberty petitions.
6. The greatest danger is when citizens stop questioning the judiciary
We must understand something important.
The judiciary is not above the Constitution. The judiciary exists because of the Constitution.
The Supreme Court is not the owner of justice. The High Courts are not private institutions. Judges are not rulers. They are constitutional functionaries entrusted with a responsibility to protect the rights of ordinary citizens.
When politicians fail, we question them.
When government officials fail, we question them.
When the police fail, we question them.
Why should the judiciary be exempt from public scrutiny?
Respecting the judiciary does not mean remaining silent about its failures. In fact, genuine respect for the institution requires us to demand that it function according to the highest constitutional standards.
We should not want weaker courts. We should want stronger, more transparent and more accountable courts.
And we should never confuse criticism of a judicial decision or administrative failure with an attack on judicial independence.
The final question: What is the value of justice after death?
Imagine being 84 years old.
Imagine suffering from Parkinson's disease.
Imagine being imprisoned, struggling even to drink a glass of water.
Imagine asking the courts for liberty.
Imagine dying before your plea is meaningfully resolved.
And imagine that five years later, a court tells the world that your petition has become infructuous because you are dead.
What a tragic irony.
The purpose of justice is not merely to dispose of files, close cases and update court records.
The purpose of justice is to protect human beings, their dignity, their liberty and their fundamental rights.
A justice system that cannot provide timely justice to a dying prisoner must ask itself some very uncomfortable questions.
Father Stan Swamy cannot come back. But his case must not become just another entry in the statistics of disposed petitions.
Let his death become a reason to examine the system, question institutional failures and demand reform.
Because tomorrow, it may not be Father Stan Swamy.
It could be an ordinary citizen, a journalist, a student, a political worker, a social activist or someone who has absolutely no influence or connections.
And when that person's freedom is taken away, the only protection they may have is the Constitution and the courts.
If justice depends on who you are, how powerful you are or how influential your lawyer is, then we must ask ourselves: Are we living under the rule of law, or the rule of privilege?
Justice delayed is justice denied. But when justice arrives five years after the person seeking it has died, we must ask whether the system has forgotten the very human being it was created to protect.

Comments
Post a Comment